Breaking News on TV Cartoon - Source:  The New Yorker

Vividness Bias: An Overview and its Impact on Human Decision-Making

​The human brain is hardwired to pay more attention to information that is presented in a more vivid or memorable way. This phenomenon, known as the vividness bias, can have a significant impact on the decisions we make in our personal and professional lives.

Vividness Bias Definition:

​Vividness Bias Definition:

A cognitive bias that refers to the tendency for people to overestimate the likelihood or frequency of events based on how vivid or easily remembered they are.

For example, people often judge an event to be more likely if it is easy to imagine or if it has happened to them before. This bias can lead people to make poor decisions, such as choosing to invest in a company because it is well-known, even though there may be other, better options.

The vividness bias is also known as the availability heuristic, which is a mental shortcut that people use to make judgments about the world based on the information that is readily available to them.

While the vividness bias is a cognitive bias, it is also a type of confirmation bias, which is when people seek out information that supports their existing beliefs and ignore evidence that contradicts them. There are a few different theories about why the vividness bias exists, but one possibility is that it is a result of evolution. Our ancestors who were better at correctly estimating the likelihood of dangerous events were more likely to survive and pass on their genes.

Another possibility is that the vividness bias is a result of the way our brains are wired. Our brains are constantly taking in information and trying to make sense of it. In order to do this, they use shortcuts, or heuristics, which sometimes lead to inaccurate judgments. By understanding the vividness bias and how it works, you can start to overcome it and make better decisions.

How to Spot Vividness Bias​

One of the most important skills you can develop as a thinker is the ability to spot vividness bias. This is when our judgments are distorted by the power of our imaginations.

For example, let's say you're considering whether to invest in a new company. You may have done your research and come up with a solid investment case. But then you imagine what could go wrong. The company could go bankrupt, the product could be a flop, the CEO could be indicted...

Suddenly, the investment doesn't look so good anymore. This is vividness bias at work.

The problem with vividness bias is that it's often hard to tell when it's affecting our judgments. Our imaginations are very powerful, and they can easily override reason and logic.

One way to guard against vividness bias is to think about how likely it is that the negative outcome you're imagining will actually happen. In the example above, you might ask yourself how likely it is that the company will actually go bankrupt, or the product will be a flop.

If you find that the negative outcome is highly unlikely, then you can safely ignore it and make your decision based on the facts. But if the negative outcome is even remotely possible, then you need to take it into account and make sure you're comfortable with the risk.

Just because a hypothetical outcome easily comes to mind, doesn't make it more probable.

So next time you're making a decision, take a moment to think about whether vividness bias might be distorting your judgment. If it is, then take steps to guard against it and make sure you're making the best decision possible.

Examples of the Vividness Bias

​We’ve all been there – caught up in the moment, caught up in the story, completely engrossed. Whether it’s a novel, a movie, or just a conversation, there are times when we become so involved that the experience feels completely real. This is the vividness bias at work.

For example, let’s say you’re planning a vacation. You’ve been wanting to go to the beach for years, but you’re also considering a trip to the mountains. When you start to think about the beach, you can picture the sun shining, the waves crashing, and the sand between your toes. It sounds perfect.

But then you start to think about the mountains, and all you can picture is cold weather, snow, and being stuck inside all day. The decision seems clear – you’re going to the beach.

But wait! The vividness bias is at work here. Just because you can picture the beach more clearly doesn’t mean it’s more likely to happen. In fact, the opposite may be true. If you live in a place where it snows, the beach may actually be further away and harder to get to than the mountains. And if you’re worried about the cold, you can always pack a coat.

The vividness bias can also lead us to believe that we’re more likely to experience positive events than negative ones. This is because, in certain scenarios, it’s often easier to imagine positive outcomes than negative ones. 

For example, let’s say you’re considering buying a lottery ticket. You know the odds of winning are slim, but you can’t help but think about what you would do with the money if you won. You would buy a new house, a new car, take a trip around the world… The list goes on. It’s much harder to think of what you would do if you lost the lottery. Sure, you would be disappointed, but it’s not like your life would be ruined. You would still have your job, your friends, and your family.

The vividness bias can lead us to make all sorts of poor decisions, from buying lottery tickets to investing in risky stocks. But it can also lead us to make more positive decisions, like taking a chance on a new business venture.

In the end, it’s important to be aware of the vividness bias and how it can influence our decisions. Just because something is more “vivid” in our minds doesn’t mean it’s more likely to happen.

The Role of Media and Technology

​Media and technology play a crucial role in amplifying and, at times, perpetuating the effects of the vividness bias in the minds of their audiences. In an age dominated by media and technology, the continuous barrage of visually engaging content, breaking news with shocking visuals, and sensational stories on social platforms can magnify this cognitive bias, leading individuals to assign greater importance or frequency to these events than they may objectively warrant.

Furthermore, technology, particularly algorithms powering social media platforms, has a propensity to prioritize and present content that garners more emotional engagement from users. This results in a feedback loop, where the most vivid and evocative stories are continually surfaced, thereby further reinforcing the vividness bias. In the long run, this can skew public perception on a range of issues, from the prevalence of certain types of events to the perceived risks or importance of particular topics, making it essential for consumers to approach media with a discerning and critical mindset.

The Effects of the Vividness Bias

​The human brain is an incredible machine, capable of processing a huge amount of information in a fraction of a second. But it’s not perfect. One of the ways it falls short is in its over-reliance on “vivid” information.

Making decisions unaware of one's own vividness bias can result in all sorts of negative effects. For one, it can lead us to overestimate the likelihood of rare but attention-grabbing events (like shark attacks or terrorist attacks) while at the same time underestimating the likelihood of more common but less attention-grabbing events (like car accidents).

It can also lead us to make bad decisions in our personal lives. For example, research has shown that people are more likely to choose surgery to treat a cancerous tumor when it is described in vivid terms (“a large mass that is quickly growing and spreading”) than when it is described in more technical terms (“a small tumor that is slowly growing and not spreading”).

Of course, there are some benefits to the vividness bias as well. It can help us remember important information and it can motivate us to take action on important issues. But overall, the negative effects of the vividness bias far outweigh the positive effects. So what can we do about it?

Strategies for Reducing the Vividness Bias

​Reducing the vividness bias requires conscious effort, as it often involves overriding intuitive emotional reactions with more logical and objective evaluations. Here are some strategies to help mitigate this bias in one's life:

  • Seek out the data and statistics. Actively look for factual information, research, and empirical evidence to balance out vivid anecdotes.
  • Evaluate source credibility. Consider the agenda and validity of sources providing vivid stories. Seek out respected, impartial sources for balanced information.
  • Look for primary sources. Review original documents, footage, transcripts, etc. to form your own assessment of events.
  • Be aware of emotional manipulation. Recognize when stories are crafted to provoke an emotional response and try to separate feelings from facts.
  • Question your assumptions. Examine your own biases and be open to information that challenges your preconceptions.
  • Diversify your media. Read, watch, and listen to sources across a wide political and cultural spectrum to avoid confirmation bias.
  • Talk to real people. Have earnest dialogues with people of different backgrounds to get nuanced perspectives.
  • Slow down judgment. When confronted with vivid stimuli, pause before reaching conclusions to let reason and logic override your initial emotional reactions.
  • Put events in context. Seek a broad understanding of issues to properly weigh vivid individual stories within larger trends and evidence.

With vigilance and effort, we can counteract vividness bias and employ critical thinking that relies more on reason than reaction. But it takes an active commitment to seeking truth over sensation.

Back to blog

Leave a comment